I've spent much of the time I normally spend checking the news in responding to the discussion Joe Taylor initiated with his flame. That's gotten me all thoughtful and shit. That plus the fact that the news for the next few days will be pure momentum effects inclines me to share a few developing thoughts and concerns.
I want to start with Open Source Politics. I was one of the original members. I dealt in detail with many of them, read maybe four of each five member blogs. This flame is not a reflection on the site, its outlook, approach or philosophy. Don't consider it as such.
I've also noticed a couple of folks who find it a problem that his attitudes are held by a progressive. Well, yeah.
But you know what? Had he kept it to himself or simply expressed them to me, it would be exactly the sort of thing I don't give a shit about.
I would not like to see any sort of ostracism; numbers count, and as long as he supports positions that I benefit from I want his number counted as regards those positions. I can handle the ones where we disagree just fine…I will not forget them, trust me.
I do feel he would benefit from associating with a more open-minded sort. No, that's wrong. He needs to hang with a more experienced sort…someone who's managed to navigate between the Scylla of liberal guilt and the Charybdis of conservative anger to an actually humane position.
Given the way he's approached this, that someone ain't gonna be me. But I would not dissociate myself from any position or organization we coincidentally support because of his presence.
Had he kept it to himself or simply expressed them to me...
I've been away from the computer for awhile so I haven't been following this closely, but one thing that really bugs me a lot is when somebody who has not visited the blog of their target to question them in the comments or contacted the target by email to express their thoughts, proceeds to publish an attack on their target by name. This has happened to me twice. I wish that it hadn't happened to you.
Posted by Al-Muhajabah at May 11, 2004 03:25 PMI actually don't mind that much, sis. He is in the process of thoroughly discrediting himself, much like that guy who came here after S-Train's shooting incident.
My name's been public from the beginning so that's not a problem either.
I don't want OSP tainted though, and I don't want this to fuel and "leftist racism" bullshit. It exists, just as it does on the right…but at least on the left it's constantly challenged.
I'm trying! I really am!
Posted by folkbum at May 11, 2004 05:52 PMYes you are. But he's not considering opinion any further than how to deflect them. The classic closed mind.
To me, the choice is now to ignore or ridicule him.
Posted by P6 at May 11, 2004 05:57 PM