It would be interesting to see all the Identity Blogging posts in a tree structure.
Terry at The Storm:
Hm.
W.E.B. DuBois, The Souls of Black Folks, I. Of Our Spiritual Strivings:
There are only three possible reactions to this dual-souled condition: Fuse them, amputate one or referee between them for the rest of your life.
Erica at Swirlspice has a post that's more about her than anything else. So of course a comment on this discussion (since she ran into it) was appropriate:
This subject has been a big thing lately. Frankly, I'm inclined to stay out of it. I have enough issues with myself as a person and I ain't tryinna drag other folks into my thought processes, so there will be no linkage here. That might be irresponsible in that I'm not providing any context for these thoughts, but oh well.
The gist of the black blogger thread seems to be that some black bloggers think the other black bloggers of the world are not representing. I don't like the idea that black people are pondering if the blogosphere "needs" a voice/portal of the black variety. If you want to do it, do it. Do it because you're interested and because you have something to offer, not because people "need" to hear what you have to say.
Why do black bloggers feel a need to amass a critical number of fellow black bloggers and say things like "we've arrived"? Everything I've read about black blogging echoes my experience living in a pretty cosmopolitan but pretty white city. There's a black culture that I don't really feel like I'm a part of, but they feel a need to bond strongly with their own and make their presence known and that amplifies the blackness vibe I get from them, which in turn makes me even more uncomfortable. I guess that makes me a northern racist (more on this in a sec). And amongst all this is where Dean called me "vaguely conservative" (the horror!).
The distinction between "black bloggers" and "bloggers who are black" has emerged. I suppose I fall into the latter category, and it flows nicely with my "I'm not political" stance. It's not something I think about.
The post has sections subtitled "Identity", "Growing as a blogger", "Race/Racism", "Gay", and
This is not intended to sound all Angry And Black or Angry And Gay. Because I'm really not. It's just fascinating to see people get all worked up and I think perhaps the energy is misdirected. But, as I've said many times, I'm no activist, I'm not so much political, and all this makes my brain hurt.
And not connected to, yet relevant to, this discussion are post from Aldahlia, Delilah at The Liminal Liberal (with 87 comments, though that seems to be as much a function of a limitation on the size of each comment as folks having a lot to say), and Kerri at Some Grrls.
Posted by P6 at September 20, 2003 06:19 PM | Trackback URL: http://www.prometheus6.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1706i knows you've got more to say than just....hmmm. :-) thanks for the attention. you know i appreciate it. :)
Well, Terry, my whole thought was along the lines of: the desire to be seen as an all-American boy isn't wrong, but it isn't possible either. I don't know you well enough to figure out whether you amputated one of the souls of fused them (I lean toward the latter, though-at least you're working on it if you haven't gotten all the way there). But either way you haven't changed the mind of the conservative crew you mentioned.
Since we went personal for a minute, I'll report my own solution was the fusion method.
i'm trying to fuse them...somehow it works sometimes, and other times i get looked at like i'm insane.
It's not the easiest thing.
You have to get used to being "forgiven" for your eccentricities…the ones you don't find eccentric at all. But once you catch the rhythm it's pretty cool because you get to mess with EVERYbody's head. On the other hand, you'll always be aware that you are seen as a little bit "other". Part of the reason I said you CAN'T be seen as All American boy.
That's been my experience, but obviously I do stuff different than you do. Your mileage may vary, as they say. No matter what, your experience will be different than mine. How much so is a matter for you to decide.