Everyone agrees with The Race Guy

Good thing I posted that opinion about Den yesterday. I wouldn't want to seem like a copycat. Now that I've started, though…

Incidentally, this is why I haven't endorsed anyone yet. It's important to see their positions, the inevitable problems and challenges, and how they respond. Handling this would be better than letting it blow over, but the handling must be subtle.



NY Times:
…by yesterday he made clear that he realized that his "clumsy" handling of the issue had become a large problem. In an interview with editors of The New York Times, he spoke of being in a "jam" and a "big contretemps." He used the phrase, "assuming we get through the current unpleasantness."

…At the same time he said his comments had been misconstrued and he did not back away from his conviction that the party had to make inroads with white Southerners noting that the Republicans "have played the race card" since 1968 and the Democrats had to find a way to win them back with issues like health insurance. He insisted "the African-American community gets this."

…He said that his main mistake had been not immediately condemning the flag during the debate, and that he had decided to change course as he came to understand that his comments had been personally offensive to two of his rivals, the Rev. Al Sharpton, who is black, and Senator John Edwards of North Carolina.

Nope. His main mistake was using the flag as a reference at all. As I said yesterday, it accurately indicates a particular demographic, so condemning the flag will be taken as an insult by them. It would have been much better to find another way of indicating them.Dean needs someone to bounce the phrasing of his main ideas off, as a sanity check. When Dean says:

"When people get in my face, I tend to get in theirs," Dr. Dean said in the interview at The Times. "Al Sharpton was in my face last night and I was not going to step one step, half a step, backwards, and I don't care who's in my face.

"I tend to be reflective rather later than sooner," he added. "Now, unfortunately, we all know that nobody's personality is perfect. So the things that make me a strong candidate are also my Achille's heel."

…it makes Hesiod's decision sound quite credible.

Is it Dean's personality? Yes and no. I was not one of the folks who argued that Dean was too hotheaded to be a successful candidate. I think his "anger," was refreshing. He injects emotion and passion into politics, without adopting off-the-wall positions on issues.

But....and here is where my qualms originated, and finally overcame my hopes:

Dean has a big mouth.

That seems like a small thing, but it isn't. It's the whole ball of wax. I guarantee you that Howard Dean will say between half a dozen and a dozen really, really stupid things during the general election that may cripple his candidacy.

It's not because he's stupid. It's because he's arrogant. He thinks he knows everything, and can just wing it.

As a result, he puts his foot in his mouth far too often.

More:

Several civil rights leaders and black Democrats who are unaligned in the presidential contest said the apology would likely be sufficient.

"He's probably stopped the hemorrhaging," said Kweisi Mfume, the president of the N.A.A.C.P., adding that Dr. Dean reached out to him on Sunday to put his flag comments into context. "It was important for him to get in front of this issue, lay his soul to bare, explain his context."

The Rev. Joseph Lowery, a founder of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, said he would not vote against Dr. Dean because of the misstep, adding, "I think what Dean said was a slip from the lip more than a dart from the heart."

But Michael Eric Dyson, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania who is a leading black cultural critic, said Dr. Dean came off as defensive and snide during the debate, "exacerbated the situation by waiting until today" to retreat, and still seems "racially insensitive."

"If you say, `I'm interested in bringing back poor white people, and Southern whites who are disaffected with the Democratic party,' that's fine," Professor Dyson said. "But to make your appeal at the expense of black folks only reinforces the perception that Democrats use black people when it's necessary, but at the same time exploit us when it's convenient."

I got much respect for Dyson, I agree that waiting to correct the gaffe was damaging, and his basic agreement with my request that white guys be invited back to the Democratic party is heartening. But since he used the code words for white guys but not the code words for Black guys, I don't think it was an attempt to exploit anti-Black racism.

Finally,from Dean:

"You can blame the media or blame my opponents, but the fact is, I've got to own my own words," Dr. Dean explained yesterday evening in Manchester. "And that's what I decided at about 3 o'clock this morning."

Yup.


Posted by Prometheus 6 on November 6, 2003 - 3:57am :: Politics
 
 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

P6,Wow ! You really got the ball rolling on the blogosphere on this issue !! As much as I try to stick to foreign affairs I'm going to have to blog on this one

Posted by  mark safranski (not verified) on November 6, 2003 - 6:02am.

Truthfully, I don't know that it was me. I do know this conversation had to be done. And it had to crash the public consciousness…the Republican Southern Strategy was a stealth campaign, and the Democratic candidates don't have time to be as subtle.

Posted by  P6 (not verified) on November 6, 2003 - 7:02am.

Thanks for taking it on.

Posted by  JC (not verified) on November 6, 2003 - 7:04am.

Someone should tell the Times that you could really say that the Republicans have been playing the race card since 1964, when they overwhelmingly voted for the Civil Rights Act (and a year later, the Voting Rights Act) over Democratic opposition.Of course, that really the Freedom Card rather than the Race Card, but we can't be bothered by reality when we are in full demagogue mode.

Posted by  phelps (not verified) on November 7, 2003 - 7:59am.