See? I told youI had

See? I told you

I had to speak on Kaus when he tried to represent Jayson Blair's plagiarism as an affirmative action problem. Well, during my layoff yesterday both CalPundit and Atrios took up the cudgel, for which I am grateful. Atrios in particular went deep and long. Start at the linked article and scroll down.

Again, gentlemen, you have my thanks for putting this in front of a much larger audience than I can reach.

Later: CalPundit followed up in nice rational fashion here and here. The second one is most interesting to me:

I'd like to make my point from the post below ultra clear. Here's a list of possible factors that contributed to the Jayson Blair scandal:
  1. Due to the Times' diversity program, Blair was pushed into a highly demanding position sooner than he should have been.
  2. The Times' personnel department didn't bother to check with the University of Maryland to see if he had actually graduated.
  3. Not enough attention was paid to the concerns of Blair's immediate supervisor.
  4. The Times has a culture where "sloppy but energetic" is considered promising.
  5. Supervisors at the Times never bother looking at their reporters' expense accounts, which would have given Blair's game away immediately.

Now do your best to put away both your liberal and conservative prejudices, and ask yourself a simple question: what changes are most likely to prevent a dedicated and clever fraud like Blair from scamming the Times in the future?

… So out of those five reasons ? and there may be others I've missed ? why would you choose to insist that only the one that's least likely to have permitted this problem to escape notice is also the only one that lots of attention should be paid to?

I'll leave that as an exercise for the reader.

Sadly, in two of the four comments readers felt up to the challenge and one stood on the very edge of the slippery slope Mac Diva talks about on Silver Rights.

posted by Prometheus 6 at 5/11/2003 01:29:49 PM |

Trackback URL for this post:

http://www.prometheus6.org/trackback/292
Posted by Prometheus 6 on May 11, 2003 - 1:29pm :: Old Site Archive