Remember, coompromise is that state of ambiguity in which everyone can claim a victory. This is the case here. The xenophobe wing is fighting for its constituency, the business wing is fighting for its constituency and the law remains unchanged.
Brilliant manuever, if you ask me.
Senate Vote Shelves Immigration Bill
By SUZANNE GAMBOA
The Associated Press
Friday, April 7, 2006; 10:53 AM
WASHINGTON -- The Senate sidetracked sweeping immigration legislation Friday, leaving in doubt prospects for passing a bill offering the hope of citizenship to millions of men, women and children living in the United States illegally.
A carefully crafted compromise that supporters had claimed could win an overwhelming majority received only 38 of the 60 votes necessary to protect it from weakening amendments by opponents.
Republicans were united in the 38-60 parliamentary vote but Democrats, who have insisted on no amendments, lost six votes from their members.
An alternative bill by Majority Leader Bill Frist _ with no provision to let illegal immigrants stay but imposing large fines on employers who hire them _ received even less support in a 36-62 test vote.
Earlier Friday, President Bush prodded lawmakers to keeping trying to reach an agreement, but both sides said the odds were increasing that a breakthrough would not occur until Congress returns from a two-week recess.
But what happened was precisely the opposite of what they said:
I mean, it looks pretty straightforward. The GOP backbenchers revolted against this bill and the party leadership then makes a peculiarly barebaced lie about it. I'm neither especially in favor of nor particularly against this particular bill, but I do think there are certain groundrules about lying for Republicans and these usually exclude lying about the explicit positions of their own members.